Nietzsche had a very specific idea of what mediocrity was, and it wasn’t what most people think. It wasn’t about being average, or lacking talent, or missing some opportunity that would have magically changed everything. Mediocrity, in his framework, was the failure to become. The slow, almost imperceptible process of settling into a version of yourself that was never really yours to begin with, and then defending that settled version like it’s something sacred. Mediocrity isn’t where you end up when you try and fail, it’s where you end up when you stop trying to become anything at all and convince yourself the stopping was a choice.

What makes his diagnosis so uncomfortable is that he wasn’t pointing at people who lack ability. He was pointing at people who have it and will never use it, because the mechanisms keeping them mediocre are disguised as virtues, or comfort, or as identity itself.

He named those mechanisms back in the 1880s, and I’m sorry to say it like this, but, they go so hard.

Here are seven of my personal favorites.

☆

1. Ressentiment: Building an identity out of what you oppose

Nietzsche borrowed this word from French deliberately. Not to be confused with resentment, which is an emotion that flares and fades. Ressentiment is an architecture. It’s what happens when someone who feels powerless takes that feeling and constructs an entire worldview around it.

The person living in ressentiment doesn’t just dislike what they can’t have, they redefine it as bad. The promotion they didn’t get is proof that the system is rigged. The relationship that didn’t want them is evidence that intimacy is a trap. The success they can’t replicate is confirmation that anyone who wins must be cheating. (Sound familiar?)

This is everywhere now. Entire online identities built not around what someone is creating but around what they’re against. The person whose whole personality is hating a political party, or the ex who’s been “healing” for three years but whose every post is still about the relationship, or the person who can’t name a single thing they want but can inventory everything they resent in breathtaking detail.

Ressentiment keeps you mediocre because it replaces the hard work of creation with the easy work of opposition. You never have to build anything. You just point at what other people built and explain why it doesn’t count.

☆

2. Herd Morality: A value system that makes mediocrity a moral good

This one is doing more work in the modern world than almost anything else Nietzsche identified, and it’s routinely misunderstood as a simple critique of conformity. But herd morality isn’t just “going along with the group,” it’s a complete value system, one that elevates equality, safety, and sameness as the highest moral goods, and treats distinction, excellence, and individual greatness as threats to be neutralized.

The herd doesn’t just prefer the average; it moralizes the average. Standing out becomes arrogance, ambition becomes selfishness, excellence becomes a form of violence against those who didn’t achieve it. The person who pushes ahead isn’t admired but resented, because their existence is an implicit accusation against everyone who stayed put.

This is the quiet engine behind a lot of contemporary moral language. When “equity” slides from meaning fairness into meaning enforced sameness of outcome, that’s herd morality. When a culture treats the desire to be exceptional as inherently suspicious, as if wanting to be great is an insult to everyone who doesn’t, that’s herd morality. When institutions flatten standards so that no one has to confront the discomfort of being outperformed, that’s the herd protecting itself from the thing it fears most: the individual who doesn’t need it.

Nietzsche’s point wasn’t that community is bad. It was that a community whose highest value is no one should stand above anyone else will produce people who can’t stand on their own at all.

7 things Nietzsche said will keep you…

Comments on this post are for paid subscribers